Updated October 16, 2026. Prices checked October 16, 2026.
Five fleece jackets cost $150 or more. The Rab Evolute Hoody scores highest. The Black Diamond Coefficient Hoody, the Marmot AirFleece Performance Hoody and the Patagonia R1 Air Full-Zip Hoody follow closely, and the Coefficient and the R1 Air breathe best. The Arc'teryx Kyanite Lightweight Hoody is the cheapest, at $150. Several of these have only one or two tests behind them, so their scores carry more doubt.
How these scores are built. Mid layers are judged mainly on warmth, which counts for 45% of the score. Breathability counts 25%, and the other two criteria count 15% each. Based on: Independent tests by OutdoorGearLab, CleverHiker, Switchback Travel and GearJunkie, manufacturer specifications and prices read on REI and brand pages. Most tests cover general outdoor use, not only hiking. We do not test products in person. 9 source pages are linked under the 5 products so you can check each finding. How we score.
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes our scores. Read the affiliate disclosure.
#
Product
Best for
Warmth
Score
1
Rab Evolute Hoody
Best warmth with breathability
8
7.9
2
Black Diamond Coefficient Hoody
Lightest warmth for its breathability
7
7.7
3
Patagonia R1 Air Full-Zip Hoody
Best for high effort
7
7.5
4
Marmot AirFleece Performance Full-Zip Hoody
Best for hiking with a pack
7.5
7.4
5
Arc'teryx Kyanite Lightweight Hoody
Comfortable and light
7
7.3
01
Rab Evolute Hoody
Best warmth with breathability, $165.00
7.9/10
Warmth 45%
8/10
Breathability 25%
9/10
Weight and packability 15%
6.5/10
Durability 15%
7/10
Pros
GearJunkie (8.6 of 10) rates warmth 8 and breathability 9.5, and CleverHiker (4.5 of 5) praises its heat retention and moisture control.
It has an under-helmet hood that zips around the chin, a fit CleverHiker rates excellent, and zippered side pockets.
Cons
GearJunkie says it sheds a light shower but wets out in heavier rain, and it lacks a large chest pocket.
Both tests miss thumb loops, and CleverHiker says the sleeve binding is hard to get over a watch. REI sells it as the Evolute Insulated Hoody, with 11 reviews.
OutdoorGearLab (80) names it its best overall fleece, Switchback Travel calls it the best performance fleece, and GearJunkie (9.1 of 10) used it on thru-hikes of the Appalachian Trail and the Tahoe Rim Trail.
It weighs 12.4 to 12.9 oz, and 43 REI owners rate it 4.8 out of 5.
Cons
GearJunkie found that it picked up holes and tears more easily than the R1 TechFace, and Switchback Travel says the fabric loses loft over time.
OutdoorGearLab found it warm under high effort, with no hood or hem adjustment, and it pills.
CleverHiker (4.4 of 5) credits flatlock seams that prevent chafing under a pack, a durable fabric and excellent heat retention with good breathability.
It weighs 10.2 oz in CleverHiker's test.
Cons
CleverHiker says the zippered hand pockets cannot be used under a hip belt, and the hood blows off if the jacket is not fully zipped.
CleverHiker is the only independent test we read, so the scores carry more doubt. Marmot's site lists the price but no owner reviews.
Readers in Germany, Canada, Spain, France, Italy, the Netherlands, Poland, the United Kingdom and Sweden are sent to their own Amazon store, where prices show in local currency. The prices on this page are US prices.
05
Arc'teryx Kyanite Lightweight Hoody
Comfortable and light, $150.00
7.3/10
Warmth 45%
7/10
Breathability 25%
8/10
Weight and packability 15%
7/10
Durability 15%
7/10
Pros
OutdoorGearLab (80) praises comfort against the skin, a weight of 10.8 oz and better pilling resistance. CleverHiker (4.5 of 5) calls it warm, stretchy, breathable and quick drying.
REI shows 80 owner reviews averaging 4.4 out of 5.
Cons
Both tests note a slim fit, and OutdoorGearLab found no chest pocket and a hood that bunches under a helmet.
CleverHiker lists $200 for this jacket, while REI sells it for $150, so we use the REI price.
Each score comes from independent tests (OutdoorGearLab, CleverHiker, Switchback Travel and GearJunkie), manufacturer specifications and the price on REI or a brand page. The tests cover general outdoor use as well as hiking, and none publishes a lab warmth rating. We do not test jackets in person. Ratings are our assessment from what the reviewers report. When the tests disagree, we use the more cautious view and say so.
The R1 Air has three independent tests. The AirFleece has one, and the others have two, so their scores carry more doubt.
What we left out
Patagonia Better Sweater ($169) and The North Face FUTUREFLEECE Full-Zip Hoodie ($170): both are well tested, but they scored lowest here. The Better Sweater is the warmest and the heaviest, with 666 REI reviews. The FUTUREFLEECE is the lightest, at 6.2 to 7.9 oz, and breathes well but is the least warm. Each ranking keeps its five best scores.
Patagonia R1 Air Zip-Neck ($145 in CleverHiker’s test): a different jacket from the full-zip hoody, and under $150.
The North Face Retro Denali ($200) and Arc’teryx Kyanite Hoody ($200): heavier casual fleeces.
Norrona Falketind Warm1 ($179): no US price read.
Patagonia R1 TechFace ($199) and Black Diamond Coefficient LT Hybrid ($229): priced, but the tests that cover them rate them for wind and cold more than for hiking.
What to look for
A hood that fits under your shell hood if you hike above the treeline
Hand pockets that clear a hip belt
A light fleece for hard climbs and a heavier one for camp, since few do both well
Questions
Why are the Patagonia Better Sweater and the FUTUREFLEECE not here?
Both cost more than $150, but they scored lowest of the seven fleeces in this price range. The Better Sweater is heavy and breathes poorly for hiking, and the FUTUREFLEECE gives the least warmth. Each ranking keeps its five best scores.
Why is the Kyanite Lightweight in Top Shelf at $150?
The mid-range band ends below $150 and Top Shelf starts at $150, the same rule every ranking here follows.
Why is The North Face Retro Denali not here?
CleverHiker (4.2 of 5), OutdoorGearLab (71) and Switchback Travel list it as a warm casual fleece that weighs 17 to 25 oz. OutdoorGearLab calls it not particularly breathable. It costs $200 on REI, and we left it out of a hiking ranking.
Why is the Norrona Falketind Warm1 missing?
CleverHiker rates it 4.2 of 5 at $179, but we did not read a US retailer price.
Where do the prices come from?
The regular price on REI, Marmot or Black Diamond on October 16, 2026. Sale and outlet prices are ignored.